
Lots of laughs and good to keep the contribution of women to the fore - still a long way to go.
Jim, I love your support. Unfortunatly, for women in the workplace the glass ceiling is as healthy as ever and I'm telling you straight, for a woman to break through the ceiling they have to behave as badly as the bad blokes. We are all pretending that it is improving but it's not.
Wow, Jim. Lighten up mate. You can keep on over-analysing the debate topic and waving the flag for Germaine Greer... the rest of us will be having a few laughs, enjoying ourselves with a glass of wine at Darling Harbour on the 27th of August!
I can't wait to hear Lisa Wilkinson and Pete FtizSimons go head to head on this topic. It will be intersting to see who wins!!
I find it strange that in this period of women actually being able to break some ceilings and receive the recognition they deserve, there is still this silly attempt to make funny something that is important. Nice girls, bad girls: isn't this all just more boxing women into some sort of category? Something they have fought so hard to stop?
I am afraid that as far as I see it, this sort of stuff does nothing to further or enhance women being viewed as professional or to be taken seriously in the workplace. Good behaviour and ethics should never be joked about. Too many women have had to make do for so long for the newer breeds of women who have not understood or taken part in the struggle for equality.
Fun maybe: tacky and demeaning - totally!
I just wanted to let you know how much fun was had by our table at the ACT conference. It was a great venue, good food, good service, and Julie McCrossin was truly memorable as the MC. I haven't laughed out loud for so long! The speakers were excellent as well.
I wish it could have gone on all afternoon.
I have been to four and this was definitely the very very best of what is always a highlight of our year in the ACT Public service.
THE SYDNEY EVENT HAS CHANGED VENUES DUE TO HIGH DEMAND. Now being held at the Sydney Convention Centre, Darling Harbour.
Extra tickets now available.
Go to the registration page to book your seat or corporate table!
Great event which we will continue to attend and invite customers to.
Bummer, would've LOVED to have seen this debate, as I class myself as a nice girl - who does tend to get walked on at times. Will have to be an early bird for the next one!!
Great goodie bags to take away :-)
It was a fun, entertaining presentation that gave opportunity to network and catch up with old colleagues
My first time attending. Fantastic!
It was a very enjoyable event, overall a great event
Thank you for a wonderful debate.
It was full of enthusiasm and great humour.
Very relevant topic given our Great Political move forward with a female PM.
And now begins the typical media/opposition witch-hunt, questioning Julia's lack of husband & 2.5 kids.
I wish I had seen this yesterday!
I really can’t believe some of these comments above, some fairly significant issues going on there.
Especially the name calling and comments on lack of education of woman who will not put their name against their opinions.
Of course woman can succeed with having ethics and being a level 5 leader.
There is a difference though with being nice and being a doormat.
See the influence strategies taught by Anthony Mclean and New Intelligence at one of the webinars last week.
Can't wait to see the debate.
Time to pull those shoulder pads out of the closet Nice and First, they are back in fashion in a big way! You can be nice, first and retro!!!
I wore big shoulder pads in the 80's and have been known to wear red stiletto shoes. I am successful in both my life and my career, first, at the top........and nice! Go me!
In my 30 years of corporate life I have seen many women rise to the top and I have seen many women fail. It seems the problem isn't with men its the fact that women are very competitive with each other in the workplace and will use all means to drag each other down. You just have to read some of the comments to understand what I mean. Saying such things as "being sneaky", "being bitches"sleeping their way to the top" and "being dumb" goes to the core of the problem with women in the workplace - they don't get on with each other!
From my experience, the only time I have seen women feel the need to be nasty to succeed is it to compete in an unfair environment. It can be either against women or against men. This isn't any different for men who feel helpless, except they're more likely to buddy up to their peers, but not always.
Unfortunately there are still workplaces that do not value a woman's expertise more highly than simply being a man. Or maybe there are bitches who are dimming another woman's sparkle?
Anon - it's not the dumb bitches we should be worried about... they're easy to read. It's the clever, sneaky bitches we need to be keeping a close eye on.
Oh please, it's my understanding that it's the bitchy girls that are the uneducated, dumb women who haven't been to uni but somehow find themselves in a position of power by either sleeping their way to the top, which still happens, or by networking to get to the top. Either way, i'm surrounded by them in the company I work for which would explain why it's a slug of an organisation, and I'm done with them.
It's the educated women that need to get ahead and stay there. It's the bitchy ones that need to be stepped down.
Chris - I've got to ask: What kind of "hot dates" have you been on where one woman is treading on the foot of another with her stiletto? I know of a few establishments in Surry Hills that cater for those types of "dates", but from my understanding they rarely serve dinner (at least not in the traditional sense).
Depends how you define 'nice' and how you define finishing 'first'. If first is : Chairman, CEO, $$$$$$$$, no matter what, then 'nice girls' and boys will probably not get there.
But if first is - income, level/ position, influence, respect, self respect, life balance, relationships, health, physical and spiritual needs fulfilled etc then good people will alway win.
I don't like the photo either ; more a dinner with a hot date, than a professional, look. A man sitting/ looking like that would also not be taken too seriously.
Being 'nice' should be applauded and treated as a means to success. What is missing is 'talking up', asking questions, and using networks.
Kate Sykes
careermums.com.au
According to the etymology dictionary 'NICE' means, foolish, stupid and senseless - so I guess yes 'NICE" girls would finish nice. HOWEVER, for me I like to think that it also stands for integrity, honesty and human kindness. If an organisation doesn't value those traits then maybe its the organisation that should finish last!
Louise Carter
Executive Director
Performance Partnership
www.performancepartnership.com.au
There are secrets to being nice?
Having learnt the secrets of 'nice' and holding that position gives me the results I want - it will be interesting to see what the other side suggest we do differently?
Coming along and look forward to hearing the arguments. I find NICE is such a horrid word (as it has some connotations of weak, meak and not willing to hold their position).
If, however, nice girls means those with integrity, who focus on the greater good and who are clear and purposeful - then I want to be counted as one of them.
Cheers,
Suzi Dafnis - Community Director
Australian Businesswomen's Network
www.abn.org.au
Sean - you're insulting Chimps there - what did they ever do...?
If it's any consolation Sarah, the types of men who gang-up on women in meetings will do the same thing to the least senior male if there are no women in the boardroom to belittle. We assume we've all evolved but sometimes we're just sitting in a room full of chimpanzees in expensive suits.
Why are women made to feel second class and unimportant when out numbered in meetings by the men?
I totally agree Anna, it depends on the way you go about assertiving yourself and the way you treat other people on the on the way up. I always believe you should treat people as you would like to be treated.
I think there's a diiference between being assertive and being a b*tch, to get ahead you have to be sure of yourself and willing to voice your opinion but you shouldn't have to do it without class and by alienating people on the way.
@ - sounds like a short lived career choice if you ask me. I reckon that would make you a b*tch by definition if you did that...
Nice managers finish second or worse, but move to first when well wishing staff slip hemlock into the tyrant's chai latte. :)
It's all about making a choice! To be or not to be.... nice, 2nd best, rough, career, family. People are reading too much into symbolism. It's about time we get real and accept people's choices for what its worth!
Oh come on Kate and Anon - I think it's mean to be a light hearted look at a very real problem. I suspect you find it offensive because you haven't got ahead.
Will we ever look beyond gender roles and simply ask, "What is useful right here, right now?" BTW, I find the photo offensive and the topic regressive.
Some people find it deeply offensive that the only way to get on in business is to be unethical. Also they think the promotional photograph is particularly offensive.
You can be nice and assertive; add respect and friendliness and appreciate an alternative view to see a larger picture. Peace and harmony for me.
Mean and manipulative people are a put off at the workplace, be it men or women. Forseeing opportunities and developing win-win solutions are the ways to get about and ahead.
Patrick: What's wrong with women being competitive? Don't you remember what it feels like to compete, and win? I never managed a Premiership in my shortlived netball career as a kid, but fortunately had more success in business and I have to say it felt fantastic!
I find it very sad that there are still women who feel compelled to 'compete' in this manner. Whatever happened to self-respect and dignity or are these now really old fashioned values?
Julia Gillard (in the video above) makes an interesting point about women leaders which she might want to reconsider, especially considering her popularity rating this morning!
And it is interesting that it is a popular choice to bully other women to get ahead rather than rely on skills and experience. Not nice girls!
Can we ever win? Be nice and you're a door mat, be strong and you're a B*tch. For educated, ambitious women, is being successful just contingent on working within the right environment and people and not whether you're nice or not?
Time for fair treatment and more power to women. We've been bullied long enough.
Julie, I couldn't agree more! I don't mean to sound sexist but its so obvious in many organisations. Maybe when the pay gap gets smaller the old fashioned boys club will also shrink.
Does anyone watch "Survivor"? "Heroes vs Villains" and the villains are winning by a big margin. I think sometimes you need to play dirty if you want to come in first.
At a certain level you hit the boys club who think they are not accountable. This can stop your career. We need top senior managers to act more ethically and more genuinely - then everyon would get a fair go.
I don't think women need to fit into the categories of "Mean Girl" or "Nice Girl". Make your own category. I like the sound of "Super Girl". Super Girl wouldn't need to bully anyone.. But she wouldn't get walked on either.
Michelle, you're just not trying hard enough. However more you girls fight... the slower your progress to the top..
Most of the ‘mean girls’ are generally nice girls but are sometimes required to be less pleasant or aggressive to achieve their goals…
This sounds to be a fascinating debate. I’m definitely interested in getting a successful woman’s perspective on the topic.
I've tried so hard to bring out my inner-mean-girl but just can't backstab my girlfriends at work. I guess it just comes naturally to some of us.
All the girls I work with seem pretty nice to me... but girls tend to be a lot more clever at disguising their dark side!
I am very much looking forward to this debate finally coming to Sydney.
In my experience you don't have to be a b*tch to be successful.
What a great debate topic, I can't wait to see the panellists revealed.

I thought the event was absolutely fantastic, just brilliant and very much looking forward to it again next year.